CYA-Free Sanitizing Solutions for Hot Tubs

Back to News

Since 1990, HydroTher Hot Tubs have been the #1 choice of architects, consultants, designers and facility operators for commercial aquatic applications.

Multiple sources, including the CDC, recommend eliminating Cyanuric Acid (CYA) from hot tubs. Yet many hot tub owners use chlorine containing CYA resulting in cloudy, smelly water in as little as a few weeks. The goal is to ensure proper disinfection while making water care easier to manage so hot tub owners are delighted with their hot tubs and rave about them to family and friends. Fortunately, there are alternatives that keep water cleaner longer without constant monitoring — thus accomplishing the goal.

CYA RECAP

According to PK Data in the APSP 2018 Yearbook, 60% of all hot tub respondents said they are sanitizing with chlorine and that dichlor is the chlorine most recommended by dealers. Dichlor is about 50% CYA. This means that for each 10 ppm of chlorine added to the water from dichlor, the CYA increase is 9 ppm.


CYA continues to build with every dose of dichlor added to the hot tub. As it builds, it slows down the ability for chlorine to kill microorganisms that can live in hot tubs. The result is that within a few weeks, hot tub owners start experiencing cloudy water that is harsh to soak in and requires far more work to keep sanitized.


CYA MAKES CHLORINE A MOVING TARGET

As CYA increases, the effectiveness of the chlorine decreases. The kill time (CT value) for pseudomonas aeruginosa (the organism that causes hot tub rash) with no CYA is about 20 seconds. It is 1 minute and 30 seconds with 50 ppm CYA and nearly 2 minutes with 100 ppm CYA. To achieve the ideal 20 second kill time would require a much greater chlorine level in the water. So, as the CYA increases you need to make a corresponding increase in the free chlorine level. This makes the free chlorine level a moving target.

The table clearly shows that more and more free chlorine is needed to attain safe water as the CYA increases from dichlor use. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) maximum for free chlorine in hot tubs is 5.0 ppm. Therefore, free chlorine levels of more than 5.0 ppm are not recommended, except when superchlorinating and when bathers are not present. Active hot tubs using dichlor could reach the 5.0 maximum within a month.

CYA BUILDUP IS FAST

If you were to add 1 1/2 teaspoons of dichlor four times a week to a 300-gallon hot tub, the CYA level would build up to 50 ppm in as few as 4 weeks and reach 100 ppm CYA in only 7 weeks. If the hot tub is used more often and dichlor is added after each use, the buildup is even faster.


CYA buildup and the increase in kill times led the CDC to issue this statement, "The CDC recommends not using cyanuric acid or chlorine products with cyanuric acid in hot tubs/ spas," published in May 2016 in a CDC article called "Your Disinfection Team: Chlorine & pH."

In December 2016, the Pennsylvania Department of Health published a statement in "Public Swimming and Bathing Places: Operational and Biological Protocol Recommendation" stating, "At even moderate levels of cyanuric acid, the amount of time it takes chlorine to kill pseudomonas aeruginosa (the bacteria that causes 'hot tub itch') can be as much as a hundred times as long as in a hot tub or spa without cyanuric acid."

PROBLEMS RUIN HOT TUB ENJOYMENT

High levels of CYA have also been known to cause corrosion because it is part of the Total Alkalinity (TA) of the water. When working with the Langelier Saturation Index (LSI) to balance water, you must account for the CYA level. To do that, subtract about 1/3 of the CYA reading from the TA reading. The result is your TA may be lower than you think. This could result in corrosive water that is damaging to surfaces and metal components and a hot tub that is unpleasant to soak in.


For hot tub owners, CYA buildup has a myriad of negative effects including cloudy and smelly water, skin irritations and worse. Even so, when disgruntled customers look for answers, they are told to add more chlorine to "shock the tub," which only compounds the problem by adding even more CYA. After as little as 2 months, there's no way for chlorine to recover. Owners are forced to empty their hot tubs prematurely, which leads to frustration and the perception that owning a hot tub is difficult.

By: Aqua Magazine - King Technology 

Back to News